Termination w.r.t. Q of the following Term Rewriting System could not be shown:
Q restricted rewrite system:
The TRS R consists of the following rules:
ap2(ap2(map, f), xs) -> ap2(ap2(ap2(if, ap2(isEmpty, xs)), f), xs)
ap2(ap2(ap2(if, true), f), xs) -> null
ap2(ap2(ap2(if, null), f), xs) -> ap2(ap2(cons, ap2(f, ap2(last, xs))), ap2(ap2(if2, f), xs))
ap2(ap2(if2, f), xs) -> ap2(ap2(map, f), ap2(dropLast, xs))
ap2(isEmpty, null) -> true
ap2(isEmpty, ap2(ap2(cons, x), xs)) -> null
ap2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, x), null)) -> x
ap2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, x), ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys))) -> ap2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys))
ap2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, x), null)) -> null
ap2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, x), ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys))) -> ap2(ap2(cons, x), ap2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys)))
Q is empty.
↳ QTRS
↳ Non-Overlap Check
Q restricted rewrite system:
The TRS R consists of the following rules:
ap2(ap2(map, f), xs) -> ap2(ap2(ap2(if, ap2(isEmpty, xs)), f), xs)
ap2(ap2(ap2(if, true), f), xs) -> null
ap2(ap2(ap2(if, null), f), xs) -> ap2(ap2(cons, ap2(f, ap2(last, xs))), ap2(ap2(if2, f), xs))
ap2(ap2(if2, f), xs) -> ap2(ap2(map, f), ap2(dropLast, xs))
ap2(isEmpty, null) -> true
ap2(isEmpty, ap2(ap2(cons, x), xs)) -> null
ap2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, x), null)) -> x
ap2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, x), ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys))) -> ap2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys))
ap2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, x), null)) -> null
ap2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, x), ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys))) -> ap2(ap2(cons, x), ap2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys)))
Q is empty.
The TRS is non-overlapping. Hence, we can switch to innermost.
↳ QTRS
↳ Non-Overlap Check
↳ QTRS
↳ DependencyPairsProof
Q restricted rewrite system:
The TRS R consists of the following rules:
ap2(ap2(map, f), xs) -> ap2(ap2(ap2(if, ap2(isEmpty, xs)), f), xs)
ap2(ap2(ap2(if, true), f), xs) -> null
ap2(ap2(ap2(if, null), f), xs) -> ap2(ap2(cons, ap2(f, ap2(last, xs))), ap2(ap2(if2, f), xs))
ap2(ap2(if2, f), xs) -> ap2(ap2(map, f), ap2(dropLast, xs))
ap2(isEmpty, null) -> true
ap2(isEmpty, ap2(ap2(cons, x), xs)) -> null
ap2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, x), null)) -> x
ap2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, x), ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys))) -> ap2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys))
ap2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, x), null)) -> null
ap2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, x), ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys))) -> ap2(ap2(cons, x), ap2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys)))
The set Q consists of the following terms:
ap2(ap2(map, x0), x1)
ap2(ap2(ap2(if, true), x0), x1)
ap2(ap2(ap2(if, null), x0), x1)
ap2(ap2(if2, x0), x1)
ap2(isEmpty, null)
ap2(isEmpty, ap2(ap2(cons, x0), x1))
ap2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, x0), null))
ap2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, x0), ap2(ap2(cons, x1), x2)))
ap2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, x0), null))
ap2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, x0), ap2(ap2(cons, x1), x2)))
Q DP problem:
The TRS P consists of the following rules:
AP2(ap2(map, f), xs) -> AP2(ap2(if, ap2(isEmpty, xs)), f)
AP2(ap2(ap2(if, null), f), xs) -> AP2(f, ap2(last, xs))
AP2(ap2(ap2(if, null), f), xs) -> AP2(ap2(if2, f), xs)
AP2(ap2(map, f), xs) -> AP2(if, ap2(isEmpty, xs))
AP2(ap2(ap2(if, null), f), xs) -> AP2(cons, ap2(f, ap2(last, xs)))
AP2(ap2(ap2(if, null), f), xs) -> AP2(ap2(cons, ap2(f, ap2(last, xs))), ap2(ap2(if2, f), xs))
AP2(ap2(map, f), xs) -> AP2(isEmpty, xs)
AP2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, x), ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys))) -> AP2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys))
AP2(ap2(ap2(if, null), f), xs) -> AP2(last, xs)
AP2(ap2(if2, f), xs) -> AP2(dropLast, xs)
AP2(ap2(ap2(if, null), f), xs) -> AP2(if2, f)
AP2(ap2(map, f), xs) -> AP2(ap2(ap2(if, ap2(isEmpty, xs)), f), xs)
AP2(ap2(if2, f), xs) -> AP2(ap2(map, f), ap2(dropLast, xs))
AP2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, x), ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys))) -> AP2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys))
AP2(ap2(if2, f), xs) -> AP2(map, f)
AP2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, x), ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys))) -> AP2(ap2(cons, x), ap2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys)))
The TRS R consists of the following rules:
ap2(ap2(map, f), xs) -> ap2(ap2(ap2(if, ap2(isEmpty, xs)), f), xs)
ap2(ap2(ap2(if, true), f), xs) -> null
ap2(ap2(ap2(if, null), f), xs) -> ap2(ap2(cons, ap2(f, ap2(last, xs))), ap2(ap2(if2, f), xs))
ap2(ap2(if2, f), xs) -> ap2(ap2(map, f), ap2(dropLast, xs))
ap2(isEmpty, null) -> true
ap2(isEmpty, ap2(ap2(cons, x), xs)) -> null
ap2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, x), null)) -> x
ap2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, x), ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys))) -> ap2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys))
ap2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, x), null)) -> null
ap2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, x), ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys))) -> ap2(ap2(cons, x), ap2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys)))
The set Q consists of the following terms:
ap2(ap2(map, x0), x1)
ap2(ap2(ap2(if, true), x0), x1)
ap2(ap2(ap2(if, null), x0), x1)
ap2(ap2(if2, x0), x1)
ap2(isEmpty, null)
ap2(isEmpty, ap2(ap2(cons, x0), x1))
ap2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, x0), null))
ap2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, x0), ap2(ap2(cons, x1), x2)))
ap2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, x0), null))
ap2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, x0), ap2(ap2(cons, x1), x2)))
We have to consider all minimal (P,Q,R)-chains.
↳ QTRS
↳ Non-Overlap Check
↳ QTRS
↳ DependencyPairsProof
↳ QDP
↳ DependencyGraphProof
Q DP problem:
The TRS P consists of the following rules:
AP2(ap2(map, f), xs) -> AP2(ap2(if, ap2(isEmpty, xs)), f)
AP2(ap2(ap2(if, null), f), xs) -> AP2(f, ap2(last, xs))
AP2(ap2(ap2(if, null), f), xs) -> AP2(ap2(if2, f), xs)
AP2(ap2(map, f), xs) -> AP2(if, ap2(isEmpty, xs))
AP2(ap2(ap2(if, null), f), xs) -> AP2(cons, ap2(f, ap2(last, xs)))
AP2(ap2(ap2(if, null), f), xs) -> AP2(ap2(cons, ap2(f, ap2(last, xs))), ap2(ap2(if2, f), xs))
AP2(ap2(map, f), xs) -> AP2(isEmpty, xs)
AP2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, x), ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys))) -> AP2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys))
AP2(ap2(ap2(if, null), f), xs) -> AP2(last, xs)
AP2(ap2(if2, f), xs) -> AP2(dropLast, xs)
AP2(ap2(ap2(if, null), f), xs) -> AP2(if2, f)
AP2(ap2(map, f), xs) -> AP2(ap2(ap2(if, ap2(isEmpty, xs)), f), xs)
AP2(ap2(if2, f), xs) -> AP2(ap2(map, f), ap2(dropLast, xs))
AP2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, x), ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys))) -> AP2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys))
AP2(ap2(if2, f), xs) -> AP2(map, f)
AP2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, x), ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys))) -> AP2(ap2(cons, x), ap2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys)))
The TRS R consists of the following rules:
ap2(ap2(map, f), xs) -> ap2(ap2(ap2(if, ap2(isEmpty, xs)), f), xs)
ap2(ap2(ap2(if, true), f), xs) -> null
ap2(ap2(ap2(if, null), f), xs) -> ap2(ap2(cons, ap2(f, ap2(last, xs))), ap2(ap2(if2, f), xs))
ap2(ap2(if2, f), xs) -> ap2(ap2(map, f), ap2(dropLast, xs))
ap2(isEmpty, null) -> true
ap2(isEmpty, ap2(ap2(cons, x), xs)) -> null
ap2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, x), null)) -> x
ap2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, x), ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys))) -> ap2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys))
ap2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, x), null)) -> null
ap2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, x), ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys))) -> ap2(ap2(cons, x), ap2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys)))
The set Q consists of the following terms:
ap2(ap2(map, x0), x1)
ap2(ap2(ap2(if, true), x0), x1)
ap2(ap2(ap2(if, null), x0), x1)
ap2(ap2(if2, x0), x1)
ap2(isEmpty, null)
ap2(isEmpty, ap2(ap2(cons, x0), x1))
ap2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, x0), null))
ap2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, x0), ap2(ap2(cons, x1), x2)))
ap2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, x0), null))
ap2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, x0), ap2(ap2(cons, x1), x2)))
We have to consider all minimal (P,Q,R)-chains.
The approximation of the Dependency Graph contains 3 SCCs with 10 less nodes.
↳ QTRS
↳ Non-Overlap Check
↳ QTRS
↳ DependencyPairsProof
↳ QDP
↳ DependencyGraphProof
↳ AND
↳ QDP
↳ QDPAfsSolverProof
↳ QDP
↳ QDP
Q DP problem:
The TRS P consists of the following rules:
AP2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, x), ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys))) -> AP2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys))
The TRS R consists of the following rules:
ap2(ap2(map, f), xs) -> ap2(ap2(ap2(if, ap2(isEmpty, xs)), f), xs)
ap2(ap2(ap2(if, true), f), xs) -> null
ap2(ap2(ap2(if, null), f), xs) -> ap2(ap2(cons, ap2(f, ap2(last, xs))), ap2(ap2(if2, f), xs))
ap2(ap2(if2, f), xs) -> ap2(ap2(map, f), ap2(dropLast, xs))
ap2(isEmpty, null) -> true
ap2(isEmpty, ap2(ap2(cons, x), xs)) -> null
ap2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, x), null)) -> x
ap2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, x), ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys))) -> ap2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys))
ap2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, x), null)) -> null
ap2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, x), ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys))) -> ap2(ap2(cons, x), ap2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys)))
The set Q consists of the following terms:
ap2(ap2(map, x0), x1)
ap2(ap2(ap2(if, true), x0), x1)
ap2(ap2(ap2(if, null), x0), x1)
ap2(ap2(if2, x0), x1)
ap2(isEmpty, null)
ap2(isEmpty, ap2(ap2(cons, x0), x1))
ap2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, x0), null))
ap2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, x0), ap2(ap2(cons, x1), x2)))
ap2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, x0), null))
ap2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, x0), ap2(ap2(cons, x1), x2)))
We have to consider all minimal (P,Q,R)-chains.
By using an argument filtering and a montonic ordering, at least one Dependency Pair of this SCC can be strictly oriented.
AP2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, x), ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys))) -> AP2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys))
Used argument filtering: AP2(x1, x2) = x2
ap2(x1, x2) = ap1(x2)
Used ordering: Quasi Precedence:
trivial
↳ QTRS
↳ Non-Overlap Check
↳ QTRS
↳ DependencyPairsProof
↳ QDP
↳ DependencyGraphProof
↳ AND
↳ QDP
↳ QDPAfsSolverProof
↳ QDP
↳ PisEmptyProof
↳ QDP
↳ QDP
Q DP problem:
P is empty.
The TRS R consists of the following rules:
ap2(ap2(map, f), xs) -> ap2(ap2(ap2(if, ap2(isEmpty, xs)), f), xs)
ap2(ap2(ap2(if, true), f), xs) -> null
ap2(ap2(ap2(if, null), f), xs) -> ap2(ap2(cons, ap2(f, ap2(last, xs))), ap2(ap2(if2, f), xs))
ap2(ap2(if2, f), xs) -> ap2(ap2(map, f), ap2(dropLast, xs))
ap2(isEmpty, null) -> true
ap2(isEmpty, ap2(ap2(cons, x), xs)) -> null
ap2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, x), null)) -> x
ap2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, x), ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys))) -> ap2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys))
ap2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, x), null)) -> null
ap2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, x), ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys))) -> ap2(ap2(cons, x), ap2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys)))
The set Q consists of the following terms:
ap2(ap2(map, x0), x1)
ap2(ap2(ap2(if, true), x0), x1)
ap2(ap2(ap2(if, null), x0), x1)
ap2(ap2(if2, x0), x1)
ap2(isEmpty, null)
ap2(isEmpty, ap2(ap2(cons, x0), x1))
ap2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, x0), null))
ap2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, x0), ap2(ap2(cons, x1), x2)))
ap2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, x0), null))
ap2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, x0), ap2(ap2(cons, x1), x2)))
We have to consider all minimal (P,Q,R)-chains.
The TRS P is empty. Hence, there is no (P,Q,R) chain.
↳ QTRS
↳ Non-Overlap Check
↳ QTRS
↳ DependencyPairsProof
↳ QDP
↳ DependencyGraphProof
↳ AND
↳ QDP
↳ QDP
↳ QDPAfsSolverProof
↳ QDP
Q DP problem:
The TRS P consists of the following rules:
AP2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, x), ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys))) -> AP2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys))
The TRS R consists of the following rules:
ap2(ap2(map, f), xs) -> ap2(ap2(ap2(if, ap2(isEmpty, xs)), f), xs)
ap2(ap2(ap2(if, true), f), xs) -> null
ap2(ap2(ap2(if, null), f), xs) -> ap2(ap2(cons, ap2(f, ap2(last, xs))), ap2(ap2(if2, f), xs))
ap2(ap2(if2, f), xs) -> ap2(ap2(map, f), ap2(dropLast, xs))
ap2(isEmpty, null) -> true
ap2(isEmpty, ap2(ap2(cons, x), xs)) -> null
ap2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, x), null)) -> x
ap2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, x), ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys))) -> ap2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys))
ap2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, x), null)) -> null
ap2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, x), ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys))) -> ap2(ap2(cons, x), ap2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys)))
The set Q consists of the following terms:
ap2(ap2(map, x0), x1)
ap2(ap2(ap2(if, true), x0), x1)
ap2(ap2(ap2(if, null), x0), x1)
ap2(ap2(if2, x0), x1)
ap2(isEmpty, null)
ap2(isEmpty, ap2(ap2(cons, x0), x1))
ap2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, x0), null))
ap2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, x0), ap2(ap2(cons, x1), x2)))
ap2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, x0), null))
ap2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, x0), ap2(ap2(cons, x1), x2)))
We have to consider all minimal (P,Q,R)-chains.
By using an argument filtering and a montonic ordering, at least one Dependency Pair of this SCC can be strictly oriented.
AP2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, x), ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys))) -> AP2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys))
Used argument filtering: AP2(x1, x2) = x2
ap2(x1, x2) = ap1(x2)
Used ordering: Quasi Precedence:
trivial
↳ QTRS
↳ Non-Overlap Check
↳ QTRS
↳ DependencyPairsProof
↳ QDP
↳ DependencyGraphProof
↳ AND
↳ QDP
↳ QDP
↳ QDPAfsSolverProof
↳ QDP
↳ PisEmptyProof
↳ QDP
Q DP problem:
P is empty.
The TRS R consists of the following rules:
ap2(ap2(map, f), xs) -> ap2(ap2(ap2(if, ap2(isEmpty, xs)), f), xs)
ap2(ap2(ap2(if, true), f), xs) -> null
ap2(ap2(ap2(if, null), f), xs) -> ap2(ap2(cons, ap2(f, ap2(last, xs))), ap2(ap2(if2, f), xs))
ap2(ap2(if2, f), xs) -> ap2(ap2(map, f), ap2(dropLast, xs))
ap2(isEmpty, null) -> true
ap2(isEmpty, ap2(ap2(cons, x), xs)) -> null
ap2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, x), null)) -> x
ap2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, x), ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys))) -> ap2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys))
ap2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, x), null)) -> null
ap2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, x), ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys))) -> ap2(ap2(cons, x), ap2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys)))
The set Q consists of the following terms:
ap2(ap2(map, x0), x1)
ap2(ap2(ap2(if, true), x0), x1)
ap2(ap2(ap2(if, null), x0), x1)
ap2(ap2(if2, x0), x1)
ap2(isEmpty, null)
ap2(isEmpty, ap2(ap2(cons, x0), x1))
ap2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, x0), null))
ap2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, x0), ap2(ap2(cons, x1), x2)))
ap2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, x0), null))
ap2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, x0), ap2(ap2(cons, x1), x2)))
We have to consider all minimal (P,Q,R)-chains.
The TRS P is empty. Hence, there is no (P,Q,R) chain.
↳ QTRS
↳ Non-Overlap Check
↳ QTRS
↳ DependencyPairsProof
↳ QDP
↳ DependencyGraphProof
↳ AND
↳ QDP
↳ QDP
↳ QDP
Q DP problem:
The TRS P consists of the following rules:
AP2(ap2(ap2(if, null), f), xs) -> AP2(f, ap2(last, xs))
AP2(ap2(map, f), xs) -> AP2(ap2(ap2(if, ap2(isEmpty, xs)), f), xs)
AP2(ap2(ap2(if, null), f), xs) -> AP2(ap2(if2, f), xs)
AP2(ap2(if2, f), xs) -> AP2(ap2(map, f), ap2(dropLast, xs))
The TRS R consists of the following rules:
ap2(ap2(map, f), xs) -> ap2(ap2(ap2(if, ap2(isEmpty, xs)), f), xs)
ap2(ap2(ap2(if, true), f), xs) -> null
ap2(ap2(ap2(if, null), f), xs) -> ap2(ap2(cons, ap2(f, ap2(last, xs))), ap2(ap2(if2, f), xs))
ap2(ap2(if2, f), xs) -> ap2(ap2(map, f), ap2(dropLast, xs))
ap2(isEmpty, null) -> true
ap2(isEmpty, ap2(ap2(cons, x), xs)) -> null
ap2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, x), null)) -> x
ap2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, x), ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys))) -> ap2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys))
ap2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, x), null)) -> null
ap2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, x), ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys))) -> ap2(ap2(cons, x), ap2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, y), ys)))
The set Q consists of the following terms:
ap2(ap2(map, x0), x1)
ap2(ap2(ap2(if, true), x0), x1)
ap2(ap2(ap2(if, null), x0), x1)
ap2(ap2(if2, x0), x1)
ap2(isEmpty, null)
ap2(isEmpty, ap2(ap2(cons, x0), x1))
ap2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, x0), null))
ap2(last, ap2(ap2(cons, x0), ap2(ap2(cons, x1), x2)))
ap2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, x0), null))
ap2(dropLast, ap2(ap2(cons, x0), ap2(ap2(cons, x1), x2)))
We have to consider all minimal (P,Q,R)-chains.